Advertising

Back to plant data sheet CARLTON ARMS HOTEL

Opinions CARLTON ARMS HOTEL New York (Manhattan)

Members' reviews on CARLTON ARMS HOTEL

3.9/5

22 reviews

Value for money

Location

Cleanliness

Setting / ambience

Service

Sort by :

The ratings and reviews below reflect the subjective opinions of members and not the opinion of The Little Witty.

Alexis C.

Visited in april 2024

Lopsided building so the floors are slanted, smelly, toilet paper in the halls, noisy room on street, the door sticks, the shared bathroom is filthy, the room is crumbling and there is creepy “art”. Would give this a negative star if I could.

Pedro R.

Visited in april 2024

Lugar muy bien ubicado, tratonexcelente y familiar. Una buena opción para ir a NY a descubrir la ciudad a tope

Zoe A.

Visited in march 2024

It's like sleeping in an art museum or an artist's sketchbook which, after seeing the pictures and reading other reviews, was exactly what I was looking for. Plus the cat is cute, the coffee in the lobby is good, and the price is great for the location. It was super clean too. My partner and I had a fun time looking at all the art!

Advertising

L B.

Visited in march 2024

Old but clean. Crazy artwork.. wish our room had more! One of two beds had very comfy memory foam mattress, and one of 4 pillows was memory foam. I wish there was a sink in the hallway toilet so I wouldn’t have to return to the room to wash my hands. We did hear a lot of street noise at night but that comes with being close to a lot of things. The matcha place downstairs is excellent and there is a convenient bagel place as well

P. T.

Visited in march 2024

This place is amazing. For the past 4 years we keep coming back here whenever we want to stay in the city. Rooms are inspiring- every time is a surprise what room youll get - feels like Christmas each time we check in to this hotel :)

Nate M.

Visited in january 2024

Clean, comfortable beds, light on amenities but great location. What made a huge difference for me was the guy behind the desk, Chris from Argentina. Super friendly, recommended some great spots to eat, got us some extra blankets. The hotel is rough around the edges but we got 5 star service. Totally recommend.

Amin B.

Visited in january 2024

ein witz

Alby

Visited in december 2023

Posizione comoda, occhio che ci sono rampe di scale da fare. Stanze caratteristiche e a tratti inquietanti ma sono gusti

Estuardo c.

Visited in december 2023

Ideal si eres economista. Ambiente retro. (Tipo roquero) excelente ubicación. Lo recomiendo.

adrian

Visited in december 2023

Instalaciones viejas y estropeadas. No recomendable

Daniel S.

Visited in november 2023

This is a very quaint fleabag hotel. But however quaint, it is, first and foremost, a fleabag.

Chiara C.

Visited in november 2023

Ci siamo trovati molto bene in questa struttura, sia per la posizione, che per la gentilezza del personale. È un posto in vero stile newyorkese, che rende il soggiorno a New York ancora più divertente! Simpatico anche il gatto ????

Jose A.

Visited in november 2023

Good

How W.

Visited in november 2023

The other guests were very shy. The whole place is like an antique. Great location, charming people, and only a couple of blocks from the subway. My stay was surprisingly very quiet, I'm not sure if I got lucky or if it's because it's right next to Baruch. The only extra accommodations from the staff outside of what is in the room are tea in the lobby and towels. Didn't see a single cockroach or bedbug anywhere in the whole place.

Neila I.

Visited in november 2023

Al principio me sensibilice un poco con la temática????????y la decoración inusual..es única y muy neoyorquina de pronto te gusta????todo esta limpio..son muy atentos a tus necesidades..me dieron a escoger la habitación..baños fuera de la habitación..están limpios..no hay ascensor..no TV..lo visite ya en clima frío y abrí la ventana ya que no tiene A/C

Jean-Baptiste D.

Visited in november 2023

Awesome place out of time in the HEART of the Big Apple.

Keaton A.

Visited in november 2023

Bohemian indeed, well located and quirky Carlton Arms does a good dance between price and amenities. It is a hostel at heart but with private, spacious rooms (consider New York apartments) and communal amenities unless you spring for an ensuite. The tenement its housed in retains much of the original charm with the added artistic coating applied by quite a few different artists.

Be sure to give your room a check before selecting it, we peeked into a somewhat dizzying spiral room that may have been painful to spend considerable time in (thankfully you'll be out on the town of course). And in that vein keep an eye out for rooms in the midst of cleaning to take a look at the art. Some of it is very well done.

It's good policy to greet and pet Ned as you mount the main floor landing, he should be relaxing in the head chair after what could only be a busy night. You will notice his absence from sight as the day wears out.

It's a quirky spot that is blindingly well located at a great price. If you dont mind a bit of communality this might be a great choice for a home base.

Michael T.

Visited in november 2023

Personnel accueillant d une gentillesse formidable. La literie est correct mais la décoration de l hôtel est spéciale

Kerstin K.

Visited in october 2023

Ich fand es richtig cool....anders, aber das ist auch New York für mich ❣️❣️❣️ okay man könnte mal Staub putzen ????es war toll, ich komme wieder

Emmanuel B.

Visited in october 2023

Un endroit décalé mais central qui vous permettra de visiter Manhattan plus rapidement. Chambre propre et lit de bonne qualité nous ont permis de passer de bonnes nuits reposantes.

Lorna C.

Visited in october 2023

Lovely place. Rooms are very stylish and individually. Staff is friendly, and the location is soo central. We loved your hotel cat.

Advertising

macadam

A well located hotel for small budgets. A warm welcome. Babacool atmosphere. On the level of the decor, some rooms are really glaucous and others very pretty. The bedding could be renewed. Given its preferences for the room when booking but you find yourself with nothing...
Very interesting price (700$ per 8 nights taxes included).